The Beauty vs Geek theme was released on January 19, 2012. It was the first of many mini themes to celebrate Valentine's Day 2012 and was inspired by the reality television series Beauty and the Geek.

This theme consisted of clothing, furniture and hairs, and was split into two parts, 'beauty' for women, and 'geek' for men. The 'beauty' furniture and clothing was mainly pink and fluffy. The 'geek' items included many comical items, as well as some parody items. An example of this being the 'Geek Toilet', which looks like an Apple iPod, shaped as a toilet with the buttons 'flush', 'wash' and 'dry'.

Lots of people loved this theme for its creativity. The theme was removed in November 2012, as part of the Black Friday sales.